|
Q. What is 'NGO darshan'?
A. An AID volunteer's trip to India to visit the groups AID works with. And also what I did this winter.
Among
the many benefits claimed for ?NGO darshan' is that it can help the
inexperienced or jaded volunteer identify issues and causes closest to
his/her heart. The miraculous byproducts of ?NGO Darshan' are also said
to include the empathy it helps develop for a situation firsthand
- after all, no report or film can match the impact of personal
experience. In my recent 3-month trip to India, I found yet another
reason why these visits are important - to answer questions.
| A group of women from Chhoti Nai, Nainital dt., Uttaranchal in their village forest |
Meeting with Kumaoni women in Uttaranchal on March 8th
- International Women's Day - I found that they had as many questions
for me as I did for them. They had traveled several kilometers, some of
them on foot the entire distance, to come to the CAC (Community Action
Center) field office. CAC works with rural women and men in Nainital
and Almora districts on food security, forest regeneration and use and
other issues. (Reetu Sogani, an AID Saathi, is a staff member of CAC).
When asked about the role CAC plays in their lives, one woman replied, "Hum bahut kuch samajhte the, CAC waalon ne humein bolna sikha diya." - "We used to understand a lot of things, but the CAC people taught us to speak."
And
speak they did. They told me about their hardships, and their struggles
to combat injustice and their accomplishment of positive change in
their lives. Gradually, the focus of the conversation moved to me and
Sara, an American undergrad who was there on a 'Study Abroad' program.
We were both questioned quite intensely about our personal lives, our
motivations, and the cost of India -US travel among other matters. One
woman asked us if there are cows and buffaloes in America. Fresh off an
earlier discussion, I told them about the gruesome conditions of
livestock in the US. The women were horrified at this grave injustice
to the cow, their mother. When you go back, fight for them, they said.
I, for one, was happy to mark International Women's Day in an honest
and open discussion.
And this is not
the only dialogue I had in communities throughout India. I found myself
explaining time zones to women in Chitrakoot district, Uttar Pradesh,
discussing US farm subsidies with organic farmers in Erode district,
Tamil Nadu and analyzing the causes of communal tensions in a D.Ed.
(Diploma of Education) college in Mumbai.
A
few days after leaving Uttaranchal, I met the members of Sangtin, a
women's collective in Sitapur district, UP. This group of women, most
of whom are field workers for a local organization, have experienced
activist attention and media frenzy during outrage, such as a
particularly gruesome rape or an attack on a Dalit community. But after
the attention shifts, there is often no relief for the survivors and
field staff are left picking up the pieces. During our 16-hour
'manthan', we had an intense discussion about where genuine collection
of information ends and exploitation begins.
While
I argued on behalf of activist organizations and the media, Vibha,
Surbala and Richa (who is an AID Saathi) pointed to our conversation as
the contrast. With me, they argued, their information exchange had been
two-way. We had established a relationship. They now knew that they
could question me repeatedly in case I did not answer to their
satisfaction; that there were a lot of things they could teach me, and
things also that they could tease me about. "The personal connection
makes all the difference," was the consensus.
Why
should these personal connections matter to us? Learning to communicate
across language, educational and entitlement gaps generates new ideas
and opportunities and challenges us in unexpected ways. Not only do we
learn more about the people whose lives we want to help change, we also
discover new ways of thinking about the problems in their lives and
ours - laying thus the foundation for meaningful and lasting
partnerships. |